Underwater Fire: Studying the Submarine Volcanoes of Tonga

Fire Meets Water

Nov. 19 2017

Like a domino effect, several things happen to seawater when it comes in contact with a volcano. When a volcano is not erupting and there is hydrothermal activity, hot water with very different chemistry from seawater rises up, just like steam would over a boiling pot. It spreads out and begins to create particles, or precipitates. Some chemicals in these particles change the water’s composition and some feed certain organisms, which are two important reasons to understand how underwater volcanoes work.

During major events, like eruptions or big earthquakes, it is possible to get a larger release of water which will create a bigger, shorter-lived plume. This nevertheless changes the chemistry of the seawater, and has impacts on biological communities. Some of the larger expulsions of water will bring with them microorganisms that live down in the crust of the Earth, known as the subsurface biosphere. Furthermore, when these kinds of changes happen, the surrounding seawater will heat up, which causes it to rise and affects regional circulation patterns.

A huge community of shrimp swims around in Mature hydrothermal chimneys at Mata Ua in 2012. Quest4000 (Marum Institute)framegrab Enhanced by Ken Rubin

Invisible Giants
Most underwater volcanoes are covered by thousands of meters of water, so when experts look for them, they cannot simply spot a volcanic dome from the surface. Dr. Joseph Resing, Marine Geochemist, expands: “We have some clues, we can make maps of the seafloor and spot volcanoes, for instance. Well, there are lots of volcanoes and lots of bumps in the ocean, how are we able to tell which ones are active? We can make educated guesses based on their shape.” That is just the beginning of the story. After detecting possible active volcanoes, the scientists’ work is far from over, and to chase clues they count on technology.

The Workhorse of Oceanography
Along with geological features, chemical signatures in the water and temperature changes, are some of the most important clues the volcanoes spread around for the scientists to follow. To detect them, the team employs one of the most fundamental tools in the world of oceanography: the CTD cast.

Dr. Tamara Baumberger, Marine Geochemist, is specifically looking for two key gases suspended in the water: hydrogen and methane. Hydrogen would indicate ongoing eruptions at the seafloor, such as lava flows or explosive eruptions in which hot rocks would react to seawater and release hydrogen. “Methane gives me different information,” she says. “High methane does not necessarily indicate an eruption, but it can very well point at a smoker system or something more steady coming out of the seafloor – when hot water or fluids or biological activity releases methane.”

Particles suspended in the water are another fundamental clue.“The particulate sensor installed in the CTD, measures optical backscatter. It sends light out and detects what gets bounced back. It’s like shining a flashlight in a dusty room, you see the particles of dust flying around because that light gets bounced back to your eyes.” explains Oceanographer Sharon Walker.

On top of that, an Oxidation Reduction Potential (ORP) sensor reacts every time it detects certain chemical species in the water. For instance, before iron released by hydrothermal vents, begins to oxidize because of the oxygen in the seawater, it could be detected by the sensor. From an exploration point of view, particles do not let the scientists know where they are coming from or what they are made of. But if the sensor signals particles and the ORP sensor responds, then they know they are much closer to a source related to the volcano.

The team uses CTD casts to detect chemical signatures in the water and get a two-dimentional, vertical picture of the water column over West Mata’s summitSharon Walker

Zooming In
“One of the exciting things in this expedition is the ability to use different kinds of technology, and we decided not to try to use all of the technology at once, but to do the cruise in two parts” explains Dr. Ken Rubin, Chief Scientist. “In the first part of the cruise we are combining CTD casts with the use of an autonomous robot, an AUV. We are using it to map the seafloor in very high resolution – to be able to see things that are the size of a cantaloupe on the seafloor. At the same time we will be making chemical maps of the water above the volcanoes to look for volcanic plumes. Then we’ll go back again with ROV SuBastian, using it to make video observations, collect samples, and drive around the volcanos and see what is there.”

The AUV Sentry allows the team to connect the data from the CTD to features on the seafloor. In addition to the bathymetric and sidescan maps of the seafloor that Sentry is producing on this cruise, Dr. Walker has installed a Miniature Autonomous Plume Recorder on it. The instrument is self-contained and it samples every 5 seconds, during the entire time Sentry is diving around the volcanoes.

AUV Sentry follows a pre-defined navigation path, collecting bathymetry, sidescan and chemical data over the summit of West Mata.Sharon Walker

Two Dimensions Merge Into Three
The CTD casts provide a two-dimensional vertical picture of the water column’s chemistry and properties. Sentry’s dives produce two-dimensional horizontal scans along its path. When the two are combined, the scientists gain understanding of how all of the recorded signals intersect, making the picture much more complete.

Eighty percent of the eruptions on Earth take place in the oceans, yet underwater active volcanoes are not easy to spot. Technology is already allowing the team to detect interesting characteristics of the area, and the trail of clues begins to paint the path that ROV SuBastian will follow over the next leg of the Underwater Fire expedition.

By combining data from AUV Sentry as well as CTD readings, and them overlaying them to features on the seafloor, the team gets a comprehensive understanding of what is happening over West Mata’s summit.Sharon Walker

Share This